Sleepy Girl Gummies vs OLLY Sleep
Both are berry-style bedtime gummies. They're built differently. Here's what each brand lists on its own product page.
| Sleepy Girl Gummies | OLLY Sleep (Blackberry Zen) | |
|---|---|---|
| Key ingredients | Magnesium, L-theanine, tart cherry, apigenin | Melatonin, L-theanine, chamomile, passionflower, lemon balm |
| Melatonin listed as an ingredient | Not listed. Supplement Facts per 2 gummies: Magnesium 150mg, Tart Cherry Extract 150mg, L-Theanine 150mg, Apigenin 75mg. | Yes |
| Serving | 2 gummies; 30 servings per jar. | 2 gummies; 25 or 35 servings per bottle, 30 or 60 per pouch. |
| Gelling agent / diet | Vegan, gluten-free, non-GMO (per our product page) | Gelatin and pectin listed |
| Flavor | Berry | Blackberry with a hint of mint |
| Price | $49.99 one-time (30 servings), or $39.99 every 4 weeks with Subscribe & Save. | From $13.99 for 25 servings (olly.com/products/sleep) |
| Shipping | Free on orders $75+, otherwise $9.99. | Flat $6.99, free over $49 (olly.com) |
| Returns | All sales are final | 30-day returns (olly.com) |
Who might prefer which
- If you specifically want melatonin, OLLY Sleep lists it.
- If you want a vegan gummy built on magnesium, L-theanine, tart cherry and apigenin, that's Sleepy Girl Gummies.
- The name comes from the "sleepy girl mocktail" (tart cherry juice and magnesium). Sleepy Girl Gummies put both of those in a gummy, plus L-theanine and apigenin.
FAQ
Is OLLY Sleep vegan? OLLY lists gelatin in its other ingredients.
What's in Sleepy Girl Gummies? Per 2 gummies: Magnesium 150mg, Tart Cherry Extract 150mg, L-Theanine 150mg, Apigenin 75mg, in a berry-flavored vegan gummy.
What do customers say? Sleepy Girl Gummies have 22 reviews with a 3.91 out of 5 average, per Judge.me, the review app on our product page (checked Oct 22, 2026).
Sources: OLLY Sleep product page, https://www.olly.com/products/sleep (checked Oct 22, 2026). Sleepy Girl Gummies product page, https://pgummies.com/products/sleepy-girl-gummies.
*These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.
OLLY is a trademark of its owner. No affiliation is implied.