Best sleep gummies: how to compare them
"Best" depends on what you want in the jar. Check these four things on any label.
- Melatonin or not. Many sleep gummies are melatonin-based. Sleepy Girl Gummies list no melatonin.
- The actives and amounts. Look for exact mg per serving, not just ingredient names.
- Serving size. Some are 1 gummy, some are 2.
- Cost per serving. Divide price by servings.
Side by side
| Product | Format | Melatonin | Key actives | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sleepy Girl Gummies | Gummy, 2/serving, 30 servings | Not listed | Magnesium 150mg, Tart Cherry Extract 150mg, L-Theanine 150mg, Apigenin 75mg | pgummies.com |
| OLLY Sleep | Gummy, 2/serving | Yes | L-theanine, chamomile, passionflower, lemon balm | olly.com/products/sleep |
| Nature Made sleep gummies | Gummy | Yes (1-10 mg by product) | Melatonin; one adds magnesium | naturemade.com/collections/sleep |
| Moon Juice Magnesi-Om | Powder | Not listed | Magnesium blend, L-theanine 112mg | moonjuice.com/products/magnesi-om |
| Kin Dream Light | Drink | 0.25 mg | Magnesium 10 mg, L-theanine, reishi blend | kineuphorics.com/products/dream-light |
Sources: each brand's own product or collection page linked in the table, checked Oct 22, 2026. Products and prices may change.
Sleepy Girl Gummies at a glance
$49.99 one-time ($1.67 per serving), or $39.99 every 4 weeks with Subscribe & Save ($1.33 per serving). Free shipping on orders $75+. All sales are final.
FAQ
Are there sleep gummies without melatonin? Yes. Sleepy Girl Gummies list no melatonin; they use magnesium, L-theanine, tart cherry and apigenin.
How do I compare price? Divide the price by the number of servings.
Can I take sleep gummies every night? Follow the label and ask your healthcare provider.
*These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. Trademarks belong to their owners; no affiliation implied.